Blue Jays Manager and Star Players Troll Yankees with Ico...

The Toronto Blue Jays delivered a decisive blow to the New York Yankees, not just on the scoreboard but also in post-game celebrations, following their 5-2 victory in Game 4 of the American League Division Series on October 8, 2025. This win at Yankee Stadium clinched the ALDS 3-1 for the Blue Jays, propelling them to their first ALCS since 2016. The jubilant Toronto squad, led by manager John Schneider and star first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr., engaged in a series of pointed taunts that quickly became a major talking point across the baseball world, as reported by The New York Times.

In the champagne-soaked Blue Jays clubhouse, manager John Schneider initiated the trolling by exclaiming, "Start spreading the news!" while popping a bottle of bubbly. This direct quote from Frank Sinatra's iconic "New York, New York" song was a deliberate and ironic jab, as the anthem is traditionally played after Yankees home victories.

The song itself was also blasted loudly through the clubhouse speakers, amplifying the message and turning the Yankees' own celebratory tune against them in their home ballpark.

Not to be outdone, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. joined forces with former Boston Red Sox slugger David Ortiz during a live interview on FOX to deliver his own memorable taunt. The pair mimicked a "DAAAAAA Yankees lose!" call, a playful yet direct inversion of legendary Yankees radio announcer John Sterling's signature "THEEEEEEE Yankees win!" call.

This viral moment was particularly impactful as it unfolded in front of former Yankees greats Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez, who were also part of the FOX broadcast team.

These high-profile and audacious taunts underscore the intense rivalry between the American League East foes. The Blue Jays' decisive victory, which saw them out-hit New York 12-6 in Game 4, marked a significant achievement for a team that tied the Yankees for the AL East title and the best record in the AL, securing home-field advantage in the ALDS.

The public display of confidence and playful disrespect adds another compelling chapter to the storied competition between the two clubs.

Frank Sinatra's "New York, New York" has been an integral part of Yankee Stadium's post-game tradition since 1980, played after every home victory. The Blue Jays' deliberate choice to play this song and Manager Schneider's direct quote served as a potent form of psychological warfare, turning the Yankees' own anthem into a symbol of their defeat.
The iconic phrase "THEEEEEEE Yankees win!" was popularized by John Sterling, the long-time radio play-by-play announcer for the New York Yankees. This beloved call, deeply embedded in Yankees lore, originated from a game on May 27, 1991. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s "DAAAAAA Yankees lose!" was a direct and instantly recognizable inversion of this signature phrase.
Adding a layer of irony to the Blue Jays' celebration, the New York Yankees had previously announced in February 2025 that they would no longer play Sinatra's "New York, New York" after home losses. Instead, they planned to rotate through various other songs. This policy change made the Blue Jays' use of the song even more pointed and impactful.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s trolling was not merely verbal; it was backed by an exceptional performance throughout the ALDS. He batted an impressive .529 with three home runs and nine RBIs across the four games, consistently tormenting the Yankees' pitching. His on-field dominance provided significant credibility and amplified the impact of his post-game jabs.
Public displays of celebration and mockery, while often lighthearted, frequently serve to intensify existing sports rivalries. The Blue Jays' actions are expected to further fuel the competitive fire between Toronto and New York, promising even more heated matchups in future seasons and adding a new, memorable dimension to their already storied competition.
The taunts resonated distinctly with the two fan bases. Blue Jays supporters undoubtedly reveled in the audacious display, viewing it as a testament to their team's confidence and success. Conversely, Yankees fans likely perceived the comments as disrespectful, further stoking animosity and anticipation for future encounters.
The victory marked a significant milestone for the Blue Jays, as it was their first advancement to the American League Championship Series since 2016. The team, which tied the Yankees for the AL East title and the best record in the AL, showcased strong pitching and timely hitting throughout the series, culminating in a decisive Game 4 win.
The incident quickly garnered widespread media attention, with the video of Guerrero and Ortiz's "DAAAAAA Yankees lose!" call going viral across social media platforms. These types of moments often transcend typical sports reporting, becoming cultural touchstones that are discussed and replayed for years, cementing the Blue Jays' ALDS victory in baseball history.